Blog
Podcast
Contact
Friends

Banned Library

The Worst Library on the Internet
Blog
Podcast
Contact
Friends
Notes on the book Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dinniman

Book Club: Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dinniman (2020)

Story old as time: an ordinary person is thrust into a fight for their life for the entertainment of millions. From the Running Man to Hunger Games, literature has been filled with stories of media made murder. So here's another one.

     

Plot Summary

Carl and his ex's cat Princess Donut find themselves in an intergalactic game show video game hybrid where anything can and will happen. It's half punk rock and half sure I guess that could happen and half dammit I'm finding myself having feelings about the murder of innocent souls.

Characters

  • Carl - Our hero who finds himself with no pants or shoes, kinda like in Die Hard, but with just enough of a backstory to be a believable Dungeons and Dragons character

  • Princess Donut - A talking cat who shoots magical missiles from her eyes like Alminster if he were a talking show cat who really liked Gossip Girl

  • Mordekai - A former crawler who now gives cryptic advice and who is not going to die horribly later in the series as a mentor character

  • Hoarder / Juicer / Ball of Swine - various bosses to be slaughtered like the cattle they are because it's you or them or a hidden choice that will come up later

Setting

  • Dungeon Crawler World - Found under the earth because above the earth has been done before and that's no fun

Thoughts

  • Talking cat, total control - The rules for the world exist pretty much just for Carl and the other characters we meet. Otherwise, there's no limitation noted for biological, physical, or bureaucratic fuckery to be found and that makes me feel something odd. Both free to accept everything and angrily yelling at my Kindle "how does that fucking work in magical space land?"

  • Random bullshit - Adding on to the previous entry, while overall its a good read, I wish there was some agency of control other than an empty AI dungeon maker giving and taking away. The stakes are kill or be killed and I wish there was a central evil personification beyond man being the most evil or whatever this was about. I know this was written for the internet and probably started as a never ending story, but I needed some kind of catharsis beyond making a pig man mad and killing another pack of sad bastard monsters.

  • Naked dead lady emotional and injustice - I really felt something the first time Carl felt something. Finding that naked dead lady, knowing that another person killed her and stripped her for parts, made me and Carl angry at the injustice. People are still bastards, even when collective action would be most advantageous.

  • Cares for nursing home - when Carl decided to do what he could for the elderly that were left rather than take them out for experience points, I started to be more on his side and less "what the hell is gonna happen next."

  • Hungriest games - Yup, I just kept feeling like Mr. Dinniman got tired of his partner watching Hunger Games for the fifteenth time and decided to write his own fanfic. A very base comparison with the thousands of stories pulled to create this, but it really felt apt with live feed and sponsored content and Twitch style commentary.

  • Inventive support - I forget what this note means, so I'll say it was about the interesting ways Carl and Donut are rewarded for both being themselves and coming up with creative ways to kill various creatures. Kinda like when you ask your DM if you can roll your dwarf friend in a barrel down into the crowd of enemies and then roll a second barrel full of explosives to give the dwarf an awesome entrance and end up killing everyone and the DM just smiles and awards you experience and a bill for raising your dwarf friend from the grave so you decide that's the way you'll play from now on and become a cooper and end up making more money selling barrels than you ever did adventuring and abandon the quest and set up a little shop on the Neverwinter docks and have a family. Anyway, that's my head cannon for Billiam the Gnome Alchemist and what he's up to now, Jeremy. I didn't want to play in your game anyway.

  • Crawler's Guide to the Dungeon - Dinnamen has read Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy many times. Good for him. More people should.

  • Making friends and enemies - isn't that what it's all about anyway?

Discussion Questions

  1. If your pet gained a high intelligence and could talk and even chat with you, how annoying would that get? Would you mute them?

  2. Isn't everything fanfiction if you think about it?

  3. One time while playing D&D with my friends I did some awesome shit and Jeremy our DM punished me and I quit playing. Have you ever quit playing because of some piece of shit whose mom would not let you have real explosives in her house?

  4. If you were going to reboot Gossip Girl again, what's one character you would kill and why? How many pieces would be left of them?

  5. Many of the creatures Carl and Donut fight are amalgams of different stereotypes. If you had to create a monster from your mother-in-law and a cactus, what would you call it?

Join the Friends of the Banned Library!

Do you wish to play a game for your life? Join the Friends and compete for your life each week for mediocre cash and no prizes! Patreon.com/bannedlibrary

Older:Movie Club: How to Rob a Bank (2026) gives big V for Likes energy
PostedNovember 20, 2026
AuthorBanned Library
CategoriesBook Club
TagsDungeon Crawler Carl, Matt Dinniman, 2020

Copyright 2010-2026, Banned Library, ST Harker